• About
  • Advertise
  • Careers
Wednesday, February 24, 2021
No Result
View All Result
NEWSLETTER
Forbes
-18 °c
  • Home
    • Home – Layout 1
  • World
  • Politics
  • Business
  • Science
  • Tech
    The value of cabinet-free drive technology  Why the ESG ‘Relevancy Gap’ is Bad Business jeg empty

    The value of cabinet-free drive technology

    How Fast Is Technology Changing College Athletics? Blink, And You’ll Miss It  Why the ESG ‘Relevancy Gap’ is Bad Business jeg empty

    How Fast Is Technology Changing College Athletics? Blink, And You’ll Miss It

    INSIGHT: 5G and hotel security technology in the ’20s  Why the ESG ‘Relevancy Gap’ is Bad Business jeg empty

    INSIGHT: 5G and hotel security technology in the ’20s

    Significance of Release Agents for Die Casting Technology  Why the ESG ‘Relevancy Gap’ is Bad Business jeg empty

    Significance of Release Agents for Die Casting Technology

    APPLE IPAD PRO 5G WILL USE MILLIMETER WAVE TECHNOLOGY  Why the ESG ‘Relevancy Gap’ is Bad Business jeg empty

    APPLE IPAD PRO 5G WILL USE MILLIMETER WAVE TECHNOLOGY

    What’s hot and what’s a bot – theme park digital technology predictions for 2020  Why the ESG ‘Relevancy Gap’ is Bad Business jeg empty

    What’s hot and what’s a bot – theme park digital technology predictions for 2020

    Trending Tags

    • Sillicon Valley
    • Climate Change
    • Election Results
    • Flat Earth
    • Golden Globes
    • MotoGP 2017
    • Mr. Robot
  • Entertainment
    • All
    • Gaming
    • Movie
    • Music
    • Sports
    Asian Wrestling Championships  Why the ESG ‘Relevancy Gap’ is Bad Business jeg empty

    Star to broadcast Asian Wrestling Championships

    PSL matches in Pakistan  Why the ESG ‘Relevancy Gap’ is Bad Business jeg empty

    Looking forward to exciting PSL matches in Pakistan, says Ronchi

    Effectively using sports education to promote health and wellbeing  Why the ESG ‘Relevancy Gap’ is Bad Business jeg empty

    Effectively using sports education to promote health and wellbeing

    Dick’s Sporting Goods Is Investing Millions in Women’s Sports  Why the ESG ‘Relevancy Gap’ is Bad Business jeg empty

    Dick’s Sporting Goods Is Investing Millions in Women’s Sports

    Spotify is buying The Ringer to boost its sports podcast content  Why the ESG ‘Relevancy Gap’ is Bad Business jeg empty

    Spotify is buying The Ringer to boost its sports podcast content

    After Huge $170 Million Fine, YouTube Music Puts Limits on ‘Made for Kids’ Content  Why the ESG ‘Relevancy Gap’ is Bad Business jeg empty

    After Huge $170 Million Fine, YouTube Music Puts Limits on ‘Made for Kids’ Content

    What Song Is In The Fast & Furious 9 Trailer?  Why the ESG ‘Relevancy Gap’ is Bad Business jeg empty

    What Song Is In The Fast & Furious 9 Trailer?

    Dance music act Wolfpack on working with Fatman Scoop and updating Gabrielle’s classic hit  Why the ESG ‘Relevancy Gap’ is Bad Business jeg empty

    Dance music act Wolfpack on working with Fatman Scoop and updating Gabrielle’s classic hit

    Singer Billie Eilish sweeps top awards at Grammys  Why the ESG ‘Relevancy Gap’ is Bad Business jeg empty

    Singer Billie Eilish sweeps top awards at Grammys

  • Lifestyle
    • All
    • Fashion
    • food
    • Health
    • Travel
    Coronavirus: Test data ‘reassuring for front-line healthcare workers’  Why the ESG ‘Relevancy Gap’ is Bad Business jeg empty

    Coronavirus: Test data ‘reassuring for front-line healthcare workers’

    When the Covid-19 pandemic is over, health care must not return to business as usual  Why the ESG ‘Relevancy Gap’ is Bad Business jeg empty

    When the Covid-19 pandemic is over, health care must not return to business as usual

    Piers Morgan called Victoria Beckham a ‘pampered primadonna’ for furloughing her staff instead of paying their wages herself  Why the ESG ‘Relevancy Gap’ is Bad Business jeg empty

    Piers Morgan called Victoria Beckham a ‘pampered primadonna’ for furloughing her staff instead of paying their wages herself

    How the Apple Watch went from fashion accessory to fitness must-have  Why the ESG ‘Relevancy Gap’ is Bad Business jeg empty

    How the Apple Watch went from fashion accessory to fitness must-have

    Office Of The Attorney General Helps With COVID-19 Travel Concerns  Why the ESG ‘Relevancy Gap’ is Bad Business jeg empty

    Office Of The Attorney General Helps With COVID-19 Travel Concerns

    Cyprus’ Entry and Travel Restrictions Amid Coronavirus  Why the ESG ‘Relevancy Gap’ is Bad Business jeg empty

    Cyprus’ Entry and Travel Restrictions Amid Coronavirus

    Health care of tomorrow, today: How artificial intelligence is fighting the current, and future, COVID-19 pandemic  Why the ESG ‘Relevancy Gap’ is Bad Business jeg empty

    Health care of tomorrow, today: How artificial intelligence is fighting the current, and future, COVID-19 pandemic

    Using the magic of technology to deliver better health and care  Why the ESG ‘Relevancy Gap’ is Bad Business jeg empty

    Using the magic of technology to deliver better health and care

    How one hospital system is using technology to reduce health care providers’ exposure to coronavirus  Why the ESG ‘Relevancy Gap’ is Bad Business jeg empty

    How one hospital system is using technology to reduce health care providers’ exposure to coronavirus

    Alan raises another $54.4 million for its health insurance product  Why the ESG ‘Relevancy Gap’ is Bad Business jeg empty

    Alan raises another $54.4 million for its health insurance product

    Trending Tags

    • Golden Globes
    • Mr. Robot
    • MotoGP 2017
    • Climate Change
    • Flat Earth
  • Home
    • Home – Layout 1
  • World
  • Politics
  • Business
  • Science
  • Tech
    The value of cabinet-free drive technology  Why the ESG ‘Relevancy Gap’ is Bad Business jeg empty

    The value of cabinet-free drive technology

    How Fast Is Technology Changing College Athletics? Blink, And You’ll Miss It  Why the ESG ‘Relevancy Gap’ is Bad Business jeg empty

    How Fast Is Technology Changing College Athletics? Blink, And You’ll Miss It

    INSIGHT: 5G and hotel security technology in the ’20s  Why the ESG ‘Relevancy Gap’ is Bad Business jeg empty

    INSIGHT: 5G and hotel security technology in the ’20s

    Significance of Release Agents for Die Casting Technology  Why the ESG ‘Relevancy Gap’ is Bad Business jeg empty

    Significance of Release Agents for Die Casting Technology

    APPLE IPAD PRO 5G WILL USE MILLIMETER WAVE TECHNOLOGY  Why the ESG ‘Relevancy Gap’ is Bad Business jeg empty

    APPLE IPAD PRO 5G WILL USE MILLIMETER WAVE TECHNOLOGY

    What’s hot and what’s a bot – theme park digital technology predictions for 2020  Why the ESG ‘Relevancy Gap’ is Bad Business jeg empty

    What’s hot and what’s a bot – theme park digital technology predictions for 2020

    Trending Tags

    • Sillicon Valley
    • Climate Change
    • Election Results
    • Flat Earth
    • Golden Globes
    • MotoGP 2017
    • Mr. Robot
  • Entertainment
    • All
    • Gaming
    • Movie
    • Music
    • Sports
    Asian Wrestling Championships  Why the ESG ‘Relevancy Gap’ is Bad Business jeg empty

    Star to broadcast Asian Wrestling Championships

    PSL matches in Pakistan  Why the ESG ‘Relevancy Gap’ is Bad Business jeg empty

    Looking forward to exciting PSL matches in Pakistan, says Ronchi

    Effectively using sports education to promote health and wellbeing  Why the ESG ‘Relevancy Gap’ is Bad Business jeg empty

    Effectively using sports education to promote health and wellbeing

    Dick’s Sporting Goods Is Investing Millions in Women’s Sports  Why the ESG ‘Relevancy Gap’ is Bad Business jeg empty

    Dick’s Sporting Goods Is Investing Millions in Women’s Sports

    Spotify is buying The Ringer to boost its sports podcast content  Why the ESG ‘Relevancy Gap’ is Bad Business jeg empty

    Spotify is buying The Ringer to boost its sports podcast content

    After Huge $170 Million Fine, YouTube Music Puts Limits on ‘Made for Kids’ Content  Why the ESG ‘Relevancy Gap’ is Bad Business jeg empty

    After Huge $170 Million Fine, YouTube Music Puts Limits on ‘Made for Kids’ Content

    What Song Is In The Fast & Furious 9 Trailer?  Why the ESG ‘Relevancy Gap’ is Bad Business jeg empty

    What Song Is In The Fast & Furious 9 Trailer?

    Dance music act Wolfpack on working with Fatman Scoop and updating Gabrielle’s classic hit  Why the ESG ‘Relevancy Gap’ is Bad Business jeg empty

    Dance music act Wolfpack on working with Fatman Scoop and updating Gabrielle’s classic hit

    Singer Billie Eilish sweeps top awards at Grammys  Why the ESG ‘Relevancy Gap’ is Bad Business jeg empty

    Singer Billie Eilish sweeps top awards at Grammys

  • Lifestyle
    • All
    • Fashion
    • food
    • Health
    • Travel
    Coronavirus: Test data ‘reassuring for front-line healthcare workers’  Why the ESG ‘Relevancy Gap’ is Bad Business jeg empty

    Coronavirus: Test data ‘reassuring for front-line healthcare workers’

    When the Covid-19 pandemic is over, health care must not return to business as usual  Why the ESG ‘Relevancy Gap’ is Bad Business jeg empty

    When the Covid-19 pandemic is over, health care must not return to business as usual

    Piers Morgan called Victoria Beckham a ‘pampered primadonna’ for furloughing her staff instead of paying their wages herself  Why the ESG ‘Relevancy Gap’ is Bad Business jeg empty

    Piers Morgan called Victoria Beckham a ‘pampered primadonna’ for furloughing her staff instead of paying their wages herself

    How the Apple Watch went from fashion accessory to fitness must-have  Why the ESG ‘Relevancy Gap’ is Bad Business jeg empty

    How the Apple Watch went from fashion accessory to fitness must-have

    Office Of The Attorney General Helps With COVID-19 Travel Concerns  Why the ESG ‘Relevancy Gap’ is Bad Business jeg empty

    Office Of The Attorney General Helps With COVID-19 Travel Concerns

    Cyprus’ Entry and Travel Restrictions Amid Coronavirus  Why the ESG ‘Relevancy Gap’ is Bad Business jeg empty

    Cyprus’ Entry and Travel Restrictions Amid Coronavirus

    Health care of tomorrow, today: How artificial intelligence is fighting the current, and future, COVID-19 pandemic  Why the ESG ‘Relevancy Gap’ is Bad Business jeg empty

    Health care of tomorrow, today: How artificial intelligence is fighting the current, and future, COVID-19 pandemic

    Using the magic of technology to deliver better health and care  Why the ESG ‘Relevancy Gap’ is Bad Business jeg empty

    Using the magic of technology to deliver better health and care

    How one hospital system is using technology to reduce health care providers’ exposure to coronavirus  Why the ESG ‘Relevancy Gap’ is Bad Business jeg empty

    How one hospital system is using technology to reduce health care providers’ exposure to coronavirus

    Alan raises another $54.4 million for its health insurance product  Why the ESG ‘Relevancy Gap’ is Bad Business jeg empty

    Alan raises another $54.4 million for its health insurance product

    Trending Tags

    • Golden Globes
    • Mr. Robot
    • MotoGP 2017
    • Climate Change
    • Flat Earth
No Result
View All Result
Forbes
No Result
View All Result
Home News

Why the ESG ‘Relevancy Gap’ is Bad Business

by Mehwish Khan
14th January 2020
in Business
0
Why the ESG ‘Relevancy Gap’ is Bad Business  Why the ESG ‘Relevancy Gap’ is Bad Business jeg empty
0
SHARES
4
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

“Creative PR.” That is how Greta Thunberg, de facto leader of the growing youth climate movement and Time magazine’s Person of the Year, brands corporate America’s attempts to mask inadequate ESG (environmental, social and governance) actions. She regularly accuses the business world of “misleading” people about the authenticity of their sustainability actions in comparison to the scale of their pollution.

As an economist and former CEO, I’ve spent days reading corporate ESG reports in an attempt to face her challenge. What I found was a glaring gap between their reported ESG achievements and the most basic reporting of financial results.

This type of reporting gap, if found within a public company’s 10K annual report (as mandated for publicly-owned companies by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, or SEC), would raise serious questions of relevancy and materiality based on the accounting industry’s Generally Accepted Accounting Standards (GAAP). Such a gap in a financial report would have to be accounted for in accounting notes or it would not be certified.

Corporate America’s ESG relevancy gap is bad business because it opens the door to competition from disruptive entrepreneurs who win customers by aligning value with values. For example, the traditional food industry now confronts the competitive challenge as consumers gravitate toward meatless burgers sold through fast-food retailers that are price competitive, healthy, tasty and environmentally sustainable. Similarly, combustion turbine manufacturers are losing market share to solar and wind power. Renewable energy now represents half of new utility generating plant additions because it is least cost with zero emissions. And the auto industry is racing to catch up with Tesla, which outsells BMW and Mercedes combined because its all-electric cars deliver on price, performance and zero tailpipe emissions.

ESG initially linked value and values
Back in 2012, corporate America did link business and sustainability performance. One of my most read TriplePundit interviews was with Walmart’s Jeff Rice. What made this interview noteworthy was his linking of Walmart’s financial results to its sustainability initiatives. He powerfully summarized, “Sustainability absolutely supports everyday low prices.”

Rice also explained how Walmart was making over $200 million a year by converting what it used to throw away into cash. And he put forth a sustainable vision, describing Walmart’s self-fulfilling cycle of making money through sustainability action and using this cash flow to invest in additional sustainable best practices that would generate even more money.

But something has changed since 2012. I reached out to Walmart for an update on the financial performance provided by Rice. The response from Walmart’s representative was that I should read the company’s ESG report. I explained that I had and, finding little financial data, I was reaching out for help. Their next reply was that I should read Walmart’s financial reports. I did. These reports offered little or no links between the company’s reported ESG results and its financial results.

Thinking this might just be a Walmart issue, I then began reading other companies’ ESG reports. They were all like Walmart’s. A lot of aspirational goals and stand-alone sustainability performance with little or no context in terms of profitability or sales results.

Relevancy: The bottom-line focus for ESG reporting
Corporate America is missing a huge business opportunity by not making their ESG reports relevant to consumers and investors. Their reporting fails the millennial generation’s search for businesses that are “cool with a purpose.” They are failing to materially link their financial goals to Generation Z’s demand for change.

How could ESG reporting satisfy expectations that millennials and Gen Z have?
One example would be Walmart reporting on how its California stores are growing sales and profitability within the context of the Golden State’s 2016 public referendum banning plastic bags. I count ten Walmart stores within ten miles of my home. Their parking lots are full of cars. This economist’s guess is that Walmart sales are booming—and realizing measurable cost savings from consumers adopting the sustainable best practice of using reusable bags.

Rather than providing insights that would really gather millennial and Gen Z attention, however, Walmart reports on its 2025 aspirational goals for reducing plastic waste. The retailer does note its current success in recycling 430 million pounds of plastic, but leaves readers to wonder what percentage this recycled plastic is when accounting for Walmart’s enterprise-scale plastic waste stream. The company is silent on how much money it saves from recycling and repurposing their waste streams.

This is just not a Walmart issue.

Corporate America’s continued market share and appeal to investors are at competitive risk if they continue to delink ESG reporting and financial results. This gap will be filled by disruptive entrepreneurship that delivers the authenticity millennials and Gen Z are demanding both at the cash register and within ESG reporting.

Tags: ESGRelevancy Gap
Mehwish Khan

Mehwish Khan

Next Post
Analysis Israeli Government Faces Crucial Decision on Reining in Natural Gas Cartel  Why the ESG ‘Relevancy Gap’ is Bad Business jeg empty

Analysis Israeli Government Faces Crucial Decision on Reining in Natural Gas Cartel

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recommended

Why the ESG ‘Relevancy Gap’ is Bad Business jeg empty

Finland Has An Education System The Other Country Should Learn From

1 year ago
How To Stay Healthy When Your Child, Spouse Or Roommate Has COVID-19  Why the ESG ‘Relevancy Gap’ is Bad Business jeg empty

How To Stay Healthy When Your Child, Spouse Or Roommate Has COVID-19

10 months ago

Popular News

    Forbes

    © 2020 Forbese . All Rights Reserved.

    Forbese is a global media company, focusing on business, investing, technology, entrepreneurship!

    • About
    • Advertise
    • Careers

    Follow Us

    No Result
    View All Result
    • Home
    • Politics
    • World
    • Business
    • Science
    • National
    • Entertainment
    • Gaming
    • Movie
    • Music
    • Sports
    • Fashion
    • Lifestyle
    • Travel
    • Tech
    • Health
    • Food

    © 2020 Forbese . All Rights Reserved.

    Login to your account below

    Forgotten Password? Sign Up

    Fill the forms bellow to register

    All fields are required. Log In

    Retrieve your password

    Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

    Log In